Course Review and Comments
Play it whilst you can! This course will have to be drastically redesigned if it is to be a viable moneyspinner for the St Andrews Links Trust, because it is just too damn hard - a bit like the Jubilee course was ten years ago, which was eased considerably because no-one local would play it.
This course is an example of golf architecture beyond the limits of what is fair. Consider this - you have a blind tee shot, to a tight fairway and you blast a perfect drive, 270 yards down the middle, into an unplayable lie! Some idiot thinks that it is reasonable to have patches of long grass as features in the centre of the fairway, so you get penalised for hitting the ball straight down the middle.
The only thing missing is a laughing clown's head and a windmill on the putting greens. This really is crazy golf on a full length course.
There comes a point where a course is so brutal that the game ceases to be fun, and this course goes way beyond that point. Any ball hit into the rough is a GUARANTEED lost ball. The rough is all thigh-length thick, long grass. Penal doesn't even describe it.
I played with a group of friends who all play off single-figure handicaps and the best score was a 90, and this was on a calm day.
The positives - greens, whilst overcontoured, did putt true and the driving range was excellent. Otherwise you're better off spending less money playing the New Course in St Andrews, the best course there by far.
More user reviews for St. Andrews Links - The Castle Course
November 01st, 2012 14:56
What a stunning course- played on a sunny day and the views were magnificent. Nearly ever hole was visually superb but the 17th was spectacular . The greens are ridiculous but providing you don't take
July 29th, 2012 15:16
Such a shame. The most stunning location on the cliffs overlooking St Andrews with magnificent views of the town and St Andrews Bay. Also, some of the best designed golf holes you'll see anywhere - th
March 31st, 2012 11:20
The course is a complete contradiction. The lay out is stunning, on a par with anything. And I mean anything. The facilities are really 5 star. Staff are friendly. In fact everything is perfect, until
September 25th, 2010 23:07
The US-based Scottish golf architect David Kidd was a controversial choice to build the Castle Course but his record of creating interesting tracks out of weird bits of land won him the contract. The
September 06th, 2010 11:08
I have played this course each year since it opened. I was a fan from the beginning, but after three years I can firmly state that this is one of the best tracks in the world bar none. This is what a
June 01st, 2010 07:48
Please ignore all the negative reviews before. This is by far the most spectacular course I have ever played (we played the Old Course and Gleneagles PGA in the same weekend). The scenery is stunning.
September 21st, 2009 16:09
Great layout with fantastic views all around. As mentioned there are too many of the small mounds in the fairways which makes it very confusing to the eye when trying to line up your drive and they ca
August 06th, 2009 10:23
A must for any visit to St. Andrews.
The fact that it overlooks the water and St. Andrews cannot be underestimated. The views are spectacular. It is potentailly more difficult than the Olde Course.
April 28th, 2009 20:21
Fantastic use of the views and the sea and the wind. Green complexes are TOUGH--some have said too tough. But the major problem were hundreds of unmowed "hummocks" dotting the fairways, oft
November 12th, 2008 13:34
In the bar at Rusacks we heard how unfair this course is,the only thing unfair were the opinions of these golfers. Wonderful fairways,tees give all players a chance if they acknowleged their talent an
October 28th, 2008 09:48
They came so close to getting this golf course perfect - what the hell were they thinking with the greens? My advice is to go and play it and enjoy the views and the wonderful design from tee to green
October 24th, 2008 23:41
The greens are a farce - the wind was howling the day we played so the conditions were tought to start with but when you can hit a shot ten yards short of the green and it runs thirty yards through an
October 09th, 2008 13:10
I agree totally with the majority
of opinions- for a handicap golfer the greens verge upon unplayable.They are beautifully maintained -which only exarebates the sheer perverse lunacy of the designer!
September 23rd, 2008 20:03
Some of the best views offered anywhere in world golf. The course is tough but when played from the correct tees it is fair for all golfers. a 20 handicap played from the 6100 set with me and shot 8
September 07th, 2008 04:30
Great course, on a par with Kingsbarns, Turnberry and Royal County Down as one of the great courses in the UK. The complaints about hairy bumps in the fairway should be ignored. They are part of golf
August 04th, 2008 11:15
Great piece of land, beautiful views of St. Andrews looking over the cliffs. Overall the layout is pretty good EXCEPT for the unnecesary "hairy bumps" in the fairways. I understand stategica
July 26th, 2008 08:43
More blind tee shots than is necessary and hairy humps in the middle of fairways which also can't be seen from the tee makes driving a lottery. I have no problem with the odd undulating green to prot
Agree with this opinion? Do you think the writer missed the mark? If so
fill your own reader ranking and get us your ratings and opinions.
By the way, the opinions expressed are subjective and are those of the reviewer. They do not necessarily represent the views of WorldGolf.com LLC.
More golf courses ratings... »