Course Review and Comments
To golfers in Myrtle Beach and those who travel from many miles away, Caledonia Golf and Fish Club is Myrtle Beach golf. Since opening to the public in January 1994, Caledonia has rapidly gained and maintained a reputation as one of the premier resort courses in America. In 2016, Golf Magazine ranked Caledonia as one of the “Top 100 Courses You Can Play” and Golf Week placed it on its list of “Top 100 Resort Courses in America” for 2016 and 2017.
A quick look at the scorecard tells you that at 6,526 yards from the back tees, this Mike Strantz masterpiece is not likely to overwhelm the long hitter. But consider that it’s a par 70 course and the rating/slope from the tips is 71.8/138, and you quickly learn this course is no pushover. In fact, the White Tees at 5,710 yards (67.6/127) will show most golfers a challenge and a good time.
Ask any newcomer to the course which hole was their favorite, and the majority will choose Number 18. It’s a 377-yard par 4 that requires something less than driver off the tee. The goal here is to avoid the water and leave yourself a second shot, over water into an oddly angled green that has two tiers. The top tier tends to funnel back towards the water. Bunkers surround the green and to top things off, you may have a gallery watching your approach and putt from the balcony directly behind the green. It’s fun and intimidating at the same time!
I asked several members and Assistant Professional Mike Foley the same question and, interesting enough, all agreed that the risk/reward par 5, Number 8 was their favorite. At 512 yards from the Blue Tees, a well-struck drive off the tee over the left fairway bunker on the right leaves you with a decision. The rest of the hole plays downhill and a good drive will leave around 225 yards to the green. Again, it’s downhill, which makes it play shorter, however there is a pond in front of the green that you must carry. Something else to consider is pin location. If it’s front, it is slightly above water level. If it’s a back pin, the upper level of the green sits about four feet higher. It’s the ultimate risk/reward hole on the course.
My favorite was Number 10, a 531-yard par 5 that I almost reached in two. Fairway bunkers on either side create a narrow landing area for your drive and the waste bunker dotted with grass islands that make up the right side of the fairway is an imposing obstacle to overcome on your layup. The double-tiered green demands a good long look if you want to score well here – unfortunately I did not!
Even the short par 3, 9th hole (110 yards/Blue Tees) requires a certain amount of distance control and accuracy. Although it’s short, it’s all carry over sand, and with the green being very shallow, the two back bunkers see a lot of play. Number 7 is a short but interesting hole. It plays 346 yards from the Blue Tees and, with a right-side pin placement, 9 out of 10 players will have to play their approach shot over or under a massive moss-draped oak tree. Find the fairway bunker on the left off the tee and big numbers await.
After your round, do what many locals and other golfers do and visit the restaurant in the Old South-style clubhouse. They have a tremendous menu and, of course, your favorite post-golf libations. Now it’s your turn to sit in a porch rocker and offer encouragement on fellow golfers’ approach to the 18th green.
No round at Caledonia is complete without a souvenir of the day’s events and the pro shop can hook you up with a hat, shirt or towel from your favorite designer, complete with the Caledonia logo.
More user reviews for Caledonia Golf & Fish Club - Public
September 14th, 2015 15:10
the best golf course i have ever played. i played in hawaii, california, las vegas and michigan[habor springs) florida and my home state of ind. wow what a golf couse.
November 21st, 2013 04:38
September 14th, 2011 07:15
We have played this course every year for the past 11 years on our annual trip to MB. This course is incredible for its beauty and playability. Being from Southern California, there is no course that
July 14th, 2011 11:48
I'm pretty picky about golf courses when I'm on vacation, and this place exceeded every expectation.
From the drive into the course thru the tunnel of live oaks and Spanish moss that star
February 16th, 2010 09:11
I would love to play again and bring others including on business, but the regular greens fees are pretty stiff. I would play much more often at more competitive rates.
April 09th, 2009 09:29
You WILL talk about this course for months after you leave it. Even if your not on your best game the day you play, you will be in aww over the views, condition, and overall layout of this beautiful c
August 21st, 2008 09:52
great course great people i will play this course everytime we take our yearly trip to m beach!
June 17th, 2008 07:35
nicest greens i've ever played, along with a great layout; w/ the flowers in bloom and the wildlife everywhere, it was like playing in an arboretum; as close to Augusta National as I'll ever get
October 01st, 2007 11:42
Great Atmosphere and challenging holes. A1 clubhouse and facilities.
July 13th, 2007 23:07
Heaven in South Carolina. All the great artists seem to go before their time. As it is here, Mike Strantz's masterpiece is his legacy. Spanish moss, lines of oaks, superb conditioning and shot values,
May 23rd, 2007 03:58
Fantastic course!!! If you haven't played it it's worth the money.
Agree with this opinion? Do you think the writer missed the mark? If so
fill your own reader ranking and get us your ratings and opinions.
By the way, the opinions expressed are subjective and are those of the reviewer. They do not necessarily represent the views of WorldGolf.com LLC.
More golf courses ratings... »