Islay Golf Club Review

Islay GCIslay Golf Club in Argyll and Bute

Islay Golf Club
25 Charlotte St
Port Ellen
Isle of Islay PA42 7DF

November 11th, 2009 18:54


First Name Five off the
Last Name Tee
Handicap 12

Course Review and Comments

The real name of the course is "The Machrie" (moorland), and this is one of the truly great courses in the world. Short by today's standards, very difficult, wild rough, usually narrow fairways running through or along dunes, completely perfect turf and great natural greens. Weather can be iffy to downright awful, almost always breezy. But it doesn't matter. In anything short of a winter storm (which can occur on any day of the year), but especially if you're lucky enough to catch a wonderful sun-kissed day of light winds, playing Machrie is a life-enhancing event. If you happen to be playing alone and not distracted by the need to be good company, the beauty of the surroundings is transcendental, the experience magical and mystical.


Date course was played Sunday 16th of August 2009
Price paid for golf 32
Price comments Some kind of deal for a group. Played course 4 times
Course Design Rating
Course Design Comments Old-style "undesigned" links course. Would be 5 but I'll subtract 1 because I know there are people who won 't like the many blind shots. I got mad at them myself on occasion.
Course Greens/Fairways Condition Rating
Course Greens/Fairways Condition Comments Pristine, natural turf, relatively low usage except for late July and early August.
Course Service Rating
Course Service Comments Attached to Machrie Hotel so bar, food, friendly service all provided, if not of the standard of the Carlyle.
Course Facilities Rating
Course Facilities Comments Perfectly adequate, but far from standard of a US country club ... no course in GBI even attempts to do that or sees it as necessary in any way.
Full practice facility but not serviced ... bring your own range balls and collect them after you hit them. It is rural Scotland after all, you do things there for yourself!
Course Overall Rating
Play Again Yes
Recommend Yes

Agree with this opinion? Do you think the writer missed the mark? If so fill your own reader ranking and get us your ratings and opinions.

By the way, the opinions expressed are subjective and are those of the reviewer. They do not necessarily represent the views of LLC.

More golf courses ratings... »