Hoping for a Michelle Wie win: Because she deserves it
I’m not such a cold person. I love good things, and flowers and puppy dogs and rainbows. I want Floyd Landis to be found to have done nothing at all wrong and be cheered as a hero. I want Charles Barkley to become the governor of Alabama, and make things better for people there. I want Roy Jones Jr. to beat the chump he’s fighting over the weekend and retire with dignity.
And I want Michelle Wie to win the Evian Masters.
I want her to win because I want to see the Wie Warriors just lose it.
And because I want to see how her detractors find a way to lessen the achievement.
I want Mi-Wie to win because I want the name “Mi-Wie” to just catch fire.
And because I want to see the title of Jennifer Mario’s book, “Michelle Wie: The Making of a Champion” ring true.
I want her to win because after she does it once, she may never stop winning against the women.
But mostly, I want Michelle Wie to win the Evian Masters because she’s been a class act through this entire unprecedented experience. Her attitude, personality and willingness to share herself have been stellar. She has been charming, graceful, gawky and goofy. She is living a life no 16-year-old girl has ever lived and she is handling it brilliantly.
Close things out, Michelle. You deserve it.
–WKW
| « Bring back the 'stache! The Corey Pavin appreciation blog | Floyd Landis waits for judgement while Wie waits for Tiger's phone call » |
73 comments
_________________________
Alot is up to Karrie. If Karrie shoots 66, that makes it kind of hard.
If Karrie shoots 72, then that makes it quite a bit easier.
So, it's not like, okay Michelle let's do it. Alot depends on other players, and how they play.
It is realistically between 4 players. I doubt Laura will win. So that leaves Wie, and 2 multi-major champions, Webb and Pak.
They have the experience. So that doesn't give great odds for Wie.
If she were going up against 2 decent players it would be one thing, but if she wins against those 2, that will be a great achievement.
Can you imagine the crowds tomorrow following the final groups? Michelle has a special outfit all picked out for her tomorrow by Nike.
Wie deserves to win at some time, but it does not necessarily have to be this Evian.
As one smart Alec pointed out that it all depends on how hot Webb or Pak is. On this top level, someone who catches fire usually wins. I would bet my money on Webb.
Webb could have really run away with it today, but Wie & Pak were right there. I was almost expecting Webb to totally break away like Creamer did last year at Evian. My only regret, I wish I could watch it live.
Golfer or not, winner or not, MW is a charming young lady and I want her to attract people around the world to the world of golf.
Caveat-Is MW a Korean, an American or a Hawaiian? We all want her to be part of us and remain a global celebrity for many more years to come.
And interestingly Wie never birdies the 2nd hole, but always birdies the 3rd.
I wish. No I'm just looking at the scoreboard. Sad. I know.
Karrie Webb won. Paula Creamer shot a fantastic final round, but her 3rd round woes kept her from winning.
And Michelle Wie remains winless.
-George
Comment from: Military_Golfer [Visitor]
Correct Goerge. She is winless after a few events this year. Her poor performance has landed her only 2nds and 3rds in the tournaments.
If she posts another 2nd or 3rd next week, I think she should consider remaining in school while she is still young enogh to change careers.
*****
I never suggested Michelle should change careers, in this or any other post on the Wie topic. In fact, I've said she should do as she wishes, and that people should scrutinize her results as they see fit.
The 2nd thing I've said, starting last year, is there are other golfers who also deserve recognition along with Wie.
For example, I noted that Paula Creamer (winless in 2006) won four times in 2005, won twice on the LPGA, had a better rookie season than Anika Sorenstam, led her nation to a Solheim Cup win, and was the rookie of the year.
The disparity in attention led me to speculate whether there was some hype surrounding Michelle.
The third thing I've noted, is that when anyone posts something that stops somewhere short of being a ccomplete Michelle Wie lackey or acolyte -- in other words, somebody like you -- then the Wie Warriors (I take credit for coining that phrase, BTW) pitch a fit and respond with hyperbole.
To wit:
*****
If she posts another 2nd or 3rd next week, I think she should consider remaining in school while she is still young enogh to change careers.
*****
Military Golfer, you are straight out of central casting for the Wie Warriors. Paranoid, hyper-sensitive, angry.
It's not about Michelle, when it comes to criticism or skepticism. Heck, I think golf is the most cruel of games and I believe it is incredibly difficult to win a specific golf tournament. That's why when anybody wins a pro tournament, that's a pretty good accomplishment.
What it really is about is you and your fellow Pit Yorkies. It's about the spectacle of you Wie Warriors as you lumber in Michelle's wake, hoping to nourish yourself on a few nanoseconds of Michelle's 15 minutes, 15 months, 15 years of fame, whatever the number winds up being.
It's all about your desperation to bask in Michelle's reflected glory to validate your fandom.
-George
Perhaps you're unaware of it, but Hawaii is one of the fifty United States. Thus, if you're Hawaiian, you're American.
Bubbles is an American of Korean descent.
Of course she is at times childish......... she is, after all, a child.
I wish her and her parents all the best, ..........and Michelle, keep being yourself........you are a wonderful young lady.
Bubbles received far more than she deserves a long time ago. She'll deserve a win the moment she earns one, not a nano-second sooner.
I am neither Wie "basher" nor "warrior". Michelle has successfully learned how to compete but now needs to learn the fine art of winning.
Ah, other than, I guess Michelle just has a last name easier for headlines. See, all these reporters are trying very hard to be clever and "Wie" allows them to be creative with the titles. Althougn I always wonder why they put Michelle's picture in an article that says someone else won. Could it be that Michelle is photogenic than other girls? Unfair, totally.
Also, NOBODY deserves to win anything. Winning must be earned. So far, Michelle hasn't earned a victory. It's that simple.
You might not respect Michelle Wie, but Karrie Webb and Laura Davies do.
Congratulations Ms. Wie, you have gained alot of fans in Europe this week. Michelle drop a two iron in your bag and have some more fun next week.
As for Michelle and her handling the pressure, she is doing a fantastic job. She carries herself really well, and rarely says anything wrong. Sure, there were times when she let things slipped, but overall, she is a class act. She can carry the media, I tell you that.
On two side-notes: Michelle has earned $700,284 and has been consistently in the Top 5 in the six LPGA starts she has made this season. There are only two events left for her. Chances of her being the youngest and first non-LPGA member to break a million? Just a thought, I was wondering about.
Getting ahead of myself here, but the British Open is next week. Chances of JJ defending? Any early favorites? If I could take three, I'd pick Michelle, Karrie, and Se Ri.
One thing I am sure you know but won't admit to is that Wie has played great this year. The only tournament either Paula and Morgan have finished higher than her is in the match play chammpionship where Paula moved to the Semi's. It may be worth noting MW lost to the eventual winner.
George, that is why she is getting all the attention! It is about what have you done for me lately. Nobody remembers past glories when stuff is happening now.
Wie, is only 16, she is spanking many experienced veterans young and old in the 7 LPGA tournaments she has played this year, and she will win a tournament sooner or later. Paula and Morgan better deal with it, there is another kid on the block, and she is proving to be a load.
Over and out!
I'd like to have seen her win, too, but not this week. Paula is in sophomore slump-city, while Pressel has yet to find her game. With her, more than Wie, college might have provided an opportunity to mature, deal with mom's death some more, and season her game under Dan Brooks' tutelage at Duke. Her swing seems much more flawed than Wie's. Wie is LeBron in Cleveland to Pressel's Carmelo Anthony at 'Cuse, except that Anthony got the year at 'Cuse, which made him a better player than she his/her first year in the pro ranks.
Why couldn't I say it like that? It's so clear!
It's six events Michelle has played in to be exact. As for Morgan and Paula, you're right with Paula. The only event she placed higher than Michelle was at Match Play. It should be mentioned that Morgan Pressel (the highly-tauted, number 1 amateur, whom most said took the "right" path to golf greatness as opposed to the one Michelle is taking) has yet to place higher than Michelle in the same six events that they played in together. As a matter of fact, in the six events Michelle has played in she has more than double the earnings that Morgan won in 15 events ($700,284 as opposed to $277,457) Although, Pressel is having a decent coming-out year, it's not great to say the least.
I'm not attacking Pressel, she will have better years in her future. I just wanted to make a point to propenents of the "beating one's peers" path, going the conventional route doesn't always prove to be right. The argument doesn't hold much water anymore.
So what did you shoot today Alex? A 68 maybe?
i think michelle has proven that the path she has taken is the right one for her. all those 'do it the right way' guys should give it a rest. there have been a lot of amateur champions that have won nothing on the professional level, pressel just being the latest.
i think morgan p. will turn out to be a pretty good golfer eventually and i actually like her. but when all is said and done, whose name will likely be in the record books, hers or MW?
Guys and gals, the girl is not gonna win her first unless it is a major. Wait up, next week's tournament is a major, the Weetabix Women's British Open. MW won't settle for anything less."
I hope she loaded her two iron in the Nike jet. Take a tip from Tiger Michelle!
**Take a tip from Tiger Michelle! **
Dear M.
Thanks for your e-mail inquiry. I do have some tips for you about how not figure out how to win a professional tournament. Please see the 14-page attachment, based on the amount of help I believe you need. I hope I have the right address. You apparently didn't read the last two e-mails I sent you at your request. Even Phil read the one I sent him a couple of years ago about majors.
Sincerely, T.
We all have different opinions, and some of us are unlikely going to change them (myself included, I admit). Maybe I've been raised a different way, but my parents have always taught me of agreeing to disagree.
Notice how nobody is reacting to his antics anymore. And how long will it take him to blog something negative about her 2nd place finish at he Evian? well, he did mention something about a watch--get over it Chris, you can't have that watch.
The hype is media created and certainly can't blame Michelle for that. She just shows up at the tournaments, uses her exemptions and plays the best that she can and keeps any negative comments to herself despite some of the bitchy attitude among the LPGA players. I started to watch LPGA golf because of Michelle and have started to appreciate the other players as well. LPGA will be remiss if they don't take advantage of the fact that Michelle does attract more spectators.
She is still a teenager but with an enormous talent, poise and confidence that keeps her grinding away with a positive attitude no matter what is said about her.
Morgan Pressel did take the conventional route and so far she is struggling on the pro tour which may negate comments that Michelle should play in the junior amateur tournaments to learn how to win first. Morgan will win one day, but emotionally, she still needs to mature and get to where Michelle is and perhaps, we will see better golf out of Morgan. Either way, these young women are doing something very few people in the world get to do and they are doing it very well.
Congratulations to Kerri Webb, your experience and fine play came through this time. And Michelle you have alot of fans and supporters who want you to "just do it".
Sorenstam by 6
Pressel by 14
Lincicome by 28
Where is Dottie Peppermouth now?!
Yeah, where is Dottie Pepper? or Chris Baldwin, or Nancy Lopez?
"You ain't got IT, girl, because you ain't won no tournament, yet, and my my, everybody wins on da tour, da first year they turn pro. What? Nobody told you dat, girl?!"
Well, going head to head with Kerri, Se Ri, Lorena, and Laura and coming in second as a mere 16 year old is unheard of.
Surely, she has the talent to win every single tournament day in day out--tongue is planted firmly in my cheek, of course.
Negative and catty comments get way too much coverage. I haven't heard one negative comment from Michelle nor does she react to what's being said about her. She also kept her mouth shut and "channeled that energy into their performance.. . . ."
Professional sports is all about excellent performance and sportsmanship--although in some sports trash talk is encouraged, but golf is still a gentle women's sport.
Michelle faces the media during the best of her times and the worst of her times (such as her disqualification early in the season) and she does it with poise (no flowing tears there) and with a delightful girlish sense of humour that only those who have teenage daughters would understand. Yes, she is a very smart kid.
Getting ahead of myself here, but the British Open is next week. Chances of JJ defending? Any early favorites? If I could take three, I'd pick Michelle, Karrie, and Se Ri.
***************************
What about Annika. She will feel sad you are leaving her out of the winner candidate pool.
Is Annika going from 'world domination golfer' to now 'just another contender' ? Her domiation was during the period Pak and Webb was out in a big slump, so it was good while it lasted, but it seems she will never achieve such uncontested era again.
Indeed it is the golden era of LPGA with so much talents now that Annika is not even the top 3 choice for British Open winners.
Indeed it is the golden era of LPGA with so much talents now that Annika is not even the top 3 choice for British Open winners.
*******************************
Yes, nothing against Annika, but I'm just not feeling her. Aside from her win at the US Open, she's still feels like she's having an off year. She barely cracked the Top 10 in the Jamie Farr and the Evian. But Karrie is getting hot, and Se Ri seems to be back in shape. And with Michelle and her consistent Top 5 finishes, how can she not contend for the Open? I think Annika would probably contend too. But if I had three favorites/contenders it'll be those three. If you had to choose three early contenders, who would they be?
Note: I'm not pick the winner of the event, just those who would contend.
So Wie finishes second, and everyone has something to be happy about. People who like to watch her play, enjoy her game, and follow her as a fan are pleased with that result. The only thing displeasing about it from the fan's perspective is that those who dislike Wie will be going on and on about how failing to win shows how Michelle should still be in home economics, learning how to do the things women are supposed to do, like cooking and tending to a man. OK, so maybe only Smails goes that far. Alex and the others just want her to go away.
Anyway, don't be fooled by a name - when the content is clearly not congruous with the alleged "poster", you probably have a third-grade prank on hand. Witness the next post.
Ummm, either she IS in control of her decisions (media attention, sponsorships, men's tournaments, etc.) or she isn't. Herein lies the biggest problem of the Wie-warriors (notice I'm not hammering on Wie herself).
I fully agree. Michelle Wie isn't a neo-Feminist. She's just a girl who wants to play golf. It doesn't have to make a political statement or be for the good of the game. Why is it such an issue if she plays?
At any rate, I started watching the LPGA because of Annika. I was pretty much only watching the PGA pre-Colonial. I stuck around, because of Se Ri Pak, Grace Park and the Asian invasion. And now I watch primarily for Wiesy. I was sad that I couldn't watch Evian live, but I guess for all the hype it gets it's still not a major.
Re: British Open. I don't think one can ever discount Sorenstam, despite her sketchy play all year. Webb has got to be a favorite after the season she's having, plus she's won it 3 times previous. I think with Se Ri Pak, it's just a matter of time she's back to full form.
Wiesy is honing her game. I'm impressed at how she's reading her own putts, even though it's a bit excrutiating at times. Eventually, she'll get faster and better at it.
Obviously, sports is a what have you done lately milieu.
Yet you both suffer from reading comprehension woes. I stipulated that Paula is winless in 2006.
However, my comments referred to my observations MADE DURING 2005 that a rookie golfer such as Paula Creamer who won four times in 2005 gained far less attention than Michelle Wie DURING 2005.
My suggestion was that hype for Michelle would explain why Creamer received less media attention DURING 2005.
The responses, of course, were the usual boring and predictable from the Wie Warriors. The same whiney comments that appear in 2006 from the Wie Warriors.
In reality, nothing substantial has changed. Michelle still seeks #1.
You know, there is such a thing in the world called "bad writer." If two people misread your post, it's your problem not ours. But that's okay, since you are not competing for the Blog Shakespeare prize. I am off to work. Have fun with your Creamer vs. Wie debate.
Comment from: nongolfer [Visitor]
George,
If two people misread your post, it's your problem not ours.
*****
No, it just suggests you're both illiterate.
-George
Am I believing what I'm reading from you? When have you been so pro-Wiesy?
http://www.canada.com/topics/sports/story.html?id=d1153a25-f9a0-44ec-b123-a8eacbe8e0ce&k=19744..
Then sit back and enjoy MW instead of whining about what you all think she should be doing.
She is doing just fine, thanks!
Stop whatever you're doing and go to the hospital, now.
Comments are closed for this post.


Recent comments