Win a free golf book!

Long drive champ is not a man, baby, but she used to be

Monday December 29, 2008 | 02:39:29 pm 432 words, 3405 views  

Here’s a shocker: The woman who hit a golf ball farther than the rest of her competitors hasn’t always been a woman.

Lana Lawless, a 55-year-old bartender and local celebrity from Palm Springs, Calif., belted out a 254-yard drive into a 40 mph wind at the RE/MAX World Long Drive Championship at Mesquite (Nev.) Regional Park this fall to upset favorite Phillis Meti of Auckland, New Zealand, by four yards. Having undergone gender reassignment a few years back, the former Southern California cop has been competing legally as a woman in this event since 2006.

Now, she’s a world champion, and predictably, some are not happy about it.

In a Golfweek story by James Achenbach, three-time world champion Sean “The Beast Fister” was quoted as saying: “I am shocked more women are not complaining about this. It’s not an apples-to- apples deal. Men and women are different.”

Former women’s world champion Lee Brandon added: “In 2005, the USGA approved transgender involvement in competition, so I don’t see how we can dispute this. However, if a woman has the knees, hands and feet of a man, she has genetic real estate that is more gifted.”

And so we have controversy, although Lawless submits to frequent testing and doctor’s reports certifying she is within the normal limits of a woman.

I’m surprised this hasn’t come up before. After all, it’s been more than 30 years since Dr. Renée Richards (formerly Richard Raskind) challenged the tennis establishment to play in the U.S. Open’s women’s division and eventually compete on the women’s tour with a measurable amount of success.

And while Long Drive competitions aren’t exactly the tour, the next step seems logical. Lawless, who played to a plus-1 as a man, hasn’t announced plans to try to play on the LPGA Tour, but what if she did? And if she did make it on the LPGA Tour and started winning, what would the conversation be like? Imagine a transgendered woman capturing the U.S. Women’s Open and the disgruntled competitors who lost to her.

I have a hard time believing anyone would go through the grueling process of a sex change just to gain an advantage in sports, but at the same time, do women who used to be men have an advantage? It’s certainly a question I’m not qualified to answer, but it’s hard to believe they don’t. And if that’s the case, is it fair to the rest of the field?

There are no easy answers on this one. It’ll be interesting if someone takes this to the next level like Dr. Richards did.

Permalink 4 comments

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Deborah Sanger [Visitor]
An interesting situation, but say for instance she was playing against just men and she lost, who would be commenting that it was unfair.

She will have had significant muscle reduction due to the loss of testosterone since her sex change resulting in loss of hitting power. If she has any advantage it would most likely be in the size of her skeletal physique like length of arms and legs. In guessing here as I have never met her but I expect she is somewhere towards the upper end of the average female size.
Only 4 yards, it doesn't sound like there is much difference between her and her competitor in terms of distance. I dont suppose technique or variations in wind speed would account for her winning?
PermalinkPermalink 12/30/08 @ 03:45
Comment from: Judge Smails [Visitor]
First, you cannot "become" a member of the opposite sex. You can only mutilate yourself and become a scarred member of yours. And it's absolutely insane to allow this individual to compete with women. But, then again, we're an insane society, so I'm not surprised.
PermalinkPermalink 12/30/08 @ 20:18
Comment from: kgray [Visitor]
check 'her' DNA. if it has an XX pair, she's a girl, if it has a XY pair, he's a boy. it's science, not culture.
PermalinkPermalink 03/23/09 @ 22:27
Comment from: Sharon [Visitor]
Agree with Kgray -- But would like to add that in order to make things "FAIR" for all of us --
the contestant should provide PROOF of their BIRTH gender - before competing with an unfair advantage -- or... The other side should be permitted to use currently illegal drug enhancements --- hormones, steroids -- whatever it takes to get the advantage - This is basically what he did here.. reminds me of Dr. Richards...
PermalinkPermalink 06/15/09 @ 01:45

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>. Bloggers reserve the right to edit or delete comments. Any opinions expressed above are those of the writer and do not necessarily represent the views of the management.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))
Grass is green. What color is grass?

The Accidental Golfer The Accidental Golfer

The Accidental Golfer (AKA Mike Bailey) has spent more than 15 years writing about the game that has brought him unbridled joy and temporary bouts of insanity. Now on staff at WorldGolf.com, Bailey is a former senior editor for PGA Magazine, senior writer for Golfweek's SuperNEWS and Turfnet magazines and past president of the Texas Golf Writers Association. He has covered every facet of golf, including the PGA and LPGA Tours, equipment and course architecture, as well as the bane of his golfing existence: instruction. The last has led to at least 30 different golf swings, which all feel different but appear to his playing companions to be the same.