Golf Channel Going, Going, Gone. Sharpton on the Attack
Thursday January 10, 2008 | 12:25:47 pm 362 words, 3190 views
I apologize to anyone who may have been offended by my previous post. I will try again to address the Kelly/lynching comments in a more civil manner.
1. Kelly seems to have forgotten she was “on the air.”
2. You can’t make a “let’s lynch the black guy in the alley” comment without revealing at least a subconscious awareness that lynching black guys was a preferred method of action against blacks in particular “back in the day.”
3. The comment and apology to Tiger does not address the issue at all.
4. Of course, Tiger, being the gentleman and friend that he is would forgive her, and frankly, I don’t think he would personalize it.
5. The comment reflects a larger insensitivity from both Tilghman and the Golf Channel.
6. Rather than saying the apology ends it, she should have been suspended for a month immediately, rather than a two week vacation that only came on the heels of news covering the comments.
7. God help the Golf Channel with Al Sharpton in the hunt for Kelly’s head. It almost makes me sympathetic to her current plight.
8. I REALLY hate to see Tiger get dragged into this mess, as he has always done his best to present himself in a colorblind manner. Now, we all know that when he first came on Tour, there were those that thought he should address the “racial divide” in this country, and in a way he has, by being a master of his game and setting a wonderful example as a role model; as an athlete, as a person, as a son, and now as a father, race be damned.
9. Imus had many many years of broadcasting, and ALOT of friends in high places, and he still had to go to the woodshed for months to live down his comments.
10. Kelly has only had the anchor chair for a year, and this “mistake” isn’t going to go away quietly. Thank you You Tube, the comment will live forever. I think my first impulse if I saw her at a cocktail party would be to pull an imaginary rope up past my ear and jerk my head, but that would probably be insensitive.
Comments, Pingbacks:
Comment from: Ken [Visitor]
As a Native American and Thai I am extremely offended by the racist attack against this woman. If she was Black it would not be an issue, therefore it is an attack on her race and what her race is allowed to do and not do. The term lynch in no way indicates a crime against a black man. The term has been used since the 14th century and the crime has been commited against every race color and creed on this planet. This is about taking revenge for memories on some poor girl that went to college and actualy has a vocabulary. Al Sharpton is the worst racist I have ever seen not in a white sheet with a pointed hood.
Just to make sure its clear, the word lynch refered to Hispanics in some areas Blacks in others Irish at times Jews at other times and has been around a long time. Just because a wave of lynchings directed towards black people occured in the southern united states in the last century does not give black people the right to claim that word as their own to define as they see fit or worse yet to use as an excuse to then practice there own misdirected revenge oriented racism.
This women used the term in a poor context, but it was not racist. The attack upon her for being a white woman is absolutly racist. If she had been black it would be a different situation. That is racism, Al sharptons paycheck comes from the continued practice of it.
Just to make sure its clear, the word lynch refered to Hispanics in some areas Blacks in others Irish at times Jews at other times and has been around a long time. Just because a wave of lynchings directed towards black people occured in the southern united states in the last century does not give black people the right to claim that word as their own to define as they see fit or worse yet to use as an excuse to then practice there own misdirected revenge oriented racism.
This women used the term in a poor context, but it was not racist. The attack upon her for being a white woman is absolutly racist. If she had been black it would be a different situation. That is racism, Al sharptons paycheck comes from the continued practice of it.
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 15:23
Comment from: sam [Visitor]
ok ken, would you be offeneded if tiger was native american and she said he should be scalped. Ken your post makes nio sense, you seem to be reaching.
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 16:51
Comment from: CB MAXWELL [Member]
Ken,
You either live in a cave with internet access, or you are prone to contrariness. Yes, lynching has a long a storied history as a means of mob justice regardless of the race of the victim. But, that doesn't excuse Kelly's unfortunate comment. Couple of points, if it wasn't a racially charged comment, why did she and the Golf Channel apologize? Clearly it was construed by many, if not most observers as such. And, it is an undeniable fact of our not so distant past, that lynching of black Americans was the most recent use of the deplorable practice. In fact, I cannot recall any recent Hispanics being lynched, but maybe it didn't make cable. Again, what I find most fascinating is that when Faldo said "gang up on Tiger," that her mind would conjure up a "lynching in an alley." A football metaphor would seem more likely, or a tag team wrestling match, but a lynching? All of this serves to demonstrate how deep within the white/black consciousness is a not so veiled connection between blacks and lynching. First, from her mouth into those watching, and secondly, by how it has been attacked so strongly. The fact that it took days for the Golf Channel to get their collective heads together rather than circle the wagons speaks volumes to just how out of touch with the "real" world they are. Also, of note from my view, is the notion that Kelly just didn't see the comment as a form of subconscious racism, since on the surface, from all accounts, she is NOT a racist. Therein lies the rub. One does not have be overtly racist to harbor racist stereotypes in their head. It is just that most of us, have learned to keep it to ourselves. Or in the case of The Dog bounty hunter, save his rants for privately recorded telephone calls.
You either live in a cave with internet access, or you are prone to contrariness. Yes, lynching has a long a storied history as a means of mob justice regardless of the race of the victim. But, that doesn't excuse Kelly's unfortunate comment. Couple of points, if it wasn't a racially charged comment, why did she and the Golf Channel apologize? Clearly it was construed by many, if not most observers as such. And, it is an undeniable fact of our not so distant past, that lynching of black Americans was the most recent use of the deplorable practice. In fact, I cannot recall any recent Hispanics being lynched, but maybe it didn't make cable. Again, what I find most fascinating is that when Faldo said "gang up on Tiger," that her mind would conjure up a "lynching in an alley." A football metaphor would seem more likely, or a tag team wrestling match, but a lynching? All of this serves to demonstrate how deep within the white/black consciousness is a not so veiled connection between blacks and lynching. First, from her mouth into those watching, and secondly, by how it has been attacked so strongly. The fact that it took days for the Golf Channel to get their collective heads together rather than circle the wagons speaks volumes to just how out of touch with the "real" world they are. Also, of note from my view, is the notion that Kelly just didn't see the comment as a form of subconscious racism, since on the surface, from all accounts, she is NOT a racist. Therein lies the rub. One does not have be overtly racist to harbor racist stereotypes in their head. It is just that most of us, have learned to keep it to ourselves. Or in the case of The Dog bounty hunter, save his rants for privately recorded telephone calls.
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 17:06
Comment from: CB MAXWELL [Member]
Judge Small,
Keep it civil, keep it on topic or I will continue to delete you. The debate is, whether Kelly's comments were racist or not and the Golf Channel's responsibility in this. To make a statement that one race over another is more racist is moronic at best. INDIVIDUALS are racist, not entire races. And if you call me an idiot again, I will ask that you be removed from posting.
Keep it civil, keep it on topic or I will continue to delete you. The debate is, whether Kelly's comments were racist or not and the Golf Channel's responsibility in this. To make a statement that one race over another is more racist is moronic at best. INDIVIDUALS are racist, not entire races. And if you call me an idiot again, I will ask that you be removed from posting.
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 17:39
Comment from: Bill [Visitor]
YOU ARE ACTUALLY PERPETUATING THE PROBLEM. Tiger already said it was a non issue. End of story. Get over yourself already now. You arent that important. And as for Rev Sharpton, he has had his own gaffs and no one raises cain about that. But somebody suddenly mad him the moral authority for me and everyone else? I think not! ANd as far as the golf channel, they went way overboard as did you.
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 17:43
Comment from: Oliver Sudden [Visitor]
Regardless of what Kelly or Tiger says this is big trouble. From the Golf Channel's point of view they know sponsors don't want anybody to stop using their products because they were offended and they don't want to lose viewers. As a business you just don't want this kind of controversy. So not matter what is right I think Kelly is done.
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 18:08
Comment from: CB MAXWELL [Member]
Bill,
Read what I posted again. I am sympathetic to a point with Kelly. It was a stupid, inappropriate comment, but at it's core it is racist, even as a joke. And since it was uttered over the pubic airways, it is not for Tiger to say, non-issue, since it is an insult to blacks in general. If you read the Golf Channel's mea culpa, they too admit as much. And you are right, Sharpton is a race hustler with way too much baggage in my opinion, and has no business as the "voice of moral authority" however, he is what he is, and when HE is on your case as he is now, you better come up with something better than, "May Have Offended" apologies. My point being that had the Golf Channel recognized it as a blatantly racist "joke" they could have avoided much of the damage by suspending her for a long enough period of time for the tempest in a teapot to blow past her. By leaving her on and saying she had apologized to Tiger as if that was all there was to it, was shortsighted and stupid. And a two week suspension simply is too short. Does anyone think that after two weeks and she comes back on the air, that everyone will have forgotten? Can you imagine how "careful" with her speech she might possibly become? She was almost unlisten-able as it was, even if she is not so bad to look at.
Read what I posted again. I am sympathetic to a point with Kelly. It was a stupid, inappropriate comment, but at it's core it is racist, even as a joke. And since it was uttered over the pubic airways, it is not for Tiger to say, non-issue, since it is an insult to blacks in general. If you read the Golf Channel's mea culpa, they too admit as much. And you are right, Sharpton is a race hustler with way too much baggage in my opinion, and has no business as the "voice of moral authority" however, he is what he is, and when HE is on your case as he is now, you better come up with something better than, "May Have Offended" apologies. My point being that had the Golf Channel recognized it as a blatantly racist "joke" they could have avoided much of the damage by suspending her for a long enough period of time for the tempest in a teapot to blow past her. By leaving her on and saying she had apologized to Tiger as if that was all there was to it, was shortsighted and stupid. And a two week suspension simply is too short. Does anyone think that after two weeks and she comes back on the air, that everyone will have forgotten? Can you imagine how "careful" with her speech she might possibly become? She was almost unlisten-able as it was, even if she is not so bad to look at.
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 18:17
Comment from: Curtis [Visitor]
I wish Al Sharpton would just go away and die all ready, isn't everybody sick and tired of that racist blow hole waisting everbody time every time some one dare says something that he decides is racist, that poor girl dared joke about a black man, does he or the other racist, thats right Jesse Jackson think Kelly would ever hope that on Tiger.
Grow up and let the whale know he's not fooling us.
Thank you
Curtis
Grow up and let the whale know he's not fooling us.
Thank you
Curtis
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 21:28
Comment from: Joe Cool [Visitor]
Good grief Maxwell, get over it!! She was joking and it seems that you can not understand that. Sharpton is the biggest con in the country. He had a nice free ride running for president on the campaign trail in 2004.
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 22:44
Comment from: RonMon [Visitor] · http://mon
1. Please block those who quote Charlie Brown "Good Grief" and use the expression "Get over it." Get over what? Dig through a dictionary and find a more precise way to express yourselves.
2. This item DOES continue to be news because, unlike the previous offenders (Jimmy The Greek, Ben Wright, Don Imus), the perpetrator is a woman. America, flawed as it is, now waits to see how the drama plays out.
3. If EVER there was greater cause than this sad affair (within the realm of golf) to encourage children to learn and appreciate true and accurate use of language, I don't know of it.
2. This item DOES continue to be news because, unlike the previous offenders (Jimmy The Greek, Ben Wright, Don Imus), the perpetrator is a woman. America, flawed as it is, now waits to see how the drama plays out.
3. If EVER there was greater cause than this sad affair (within the realm of golf) to encourage children to learn and appreciate true and accurate use of language, I don't know of it.
Permalink
01/10/08 @ 23:17
Comment from: George [Visitor]
Kelly Tilghman's words were inappropriate. However if Kelly Tilghman is fired, then there should be a boycott on all minority-owned businesses for a period of ten days from the date she is fired. Also included in the boycott: any movies having minorities as leading actors and any TV shows hosted by minorities or having minorities as the leading characters. Excluded from the boycott: Tiger Woods, since he’s apparently put this behind him, and any other minority movie actor, TV host or actor, or business owner who specifically states that Kelly Tilghman should not be fired. After the ten days, it should be business as usual, as much as that is possible.
Permalink
01/11/08 @ 03:30
Comment from: Judge Smails [Visitor]
Hey,
This is just to tell you that I'll now boycott your blog just as I am Mario's, idiot.
This is just to tell you that I'll now boycott your blog just as I am Mario's, idiot.
Permalink
01/11/08 @ 13:15
Comment from: Trevor Stevens [Visitor]
CB,
Thanks for being the first blogger here to stand up to a repeated bully.
Cheers.
Thanks for being the first blogger here to stand up to a repeated bully.
Cheers.
Permalink
01/11/08 @ 13:43
Comment from: Sid [Visitor]
Tiger said this is no big deal...case
closed!
Al Sharpton [an FBI informer with overly-
processed hair] should be ignored
closed!
Al Sharpton [an FBI informer with overly-
processed hair] should be ignored
Permalink
01/11/08 @ 15:04
Comment from: merrin [Visitor]
Its funny, I think people take the opportunity to hate Al Sharpton more than actually pay attention to the causes he represents.
Why are there are those among us willing to bend over backwards to excuse ANYTHING at all, as long as Sharpton speaks out against it.
Kelly Tilghman is not some cross burning racist, but it's naive of us to really be looking for those today. Truly, she's a woman who committed a mistake on air & she should have apologized right away. made all this seem worse than it was. Her actions told me more about her qualifications than anything else. Had she mentioned putting a Japanese player in an internment camp I would still look at her askance. It's just DUMB.
Also, Thank you CB for expressing your opinion & not being daunted by the travelgolf bloggers who couch rude, racist & sometimes sexist feeling in being "ANTI-PC".
"he has always done his best to present himself in a colorblind manner. "
As much as i admire the person who doesnt drag race into everything, its impossible to be colorblind in America. We're just not meant to be that way, we're all different & we have a VERY strong American history to prove it. Tiger is his own man, makes his own decisions, and as the only Black golfer (or Coblinasian), everything seems to fall on HIS head, which isnt fair. But being colorblind isnt the answer, education is.
Why are there are those among us willing to bend over backwards to excuse ANYTHING at all, as long as Sharpton speaks out against it.
Kelly Tilghman is not some cross burning racist, but it's naive of us to really be looking for those today. Truly, she's a woman who committed a mistake on air & she should have apologized right away. made all this seem worse than it was. Her actions told me more about her qualifications than anything else. Had she mentioned putting a Japanese player in an internment camp I would still look at her askance. It's just DUMB.
Also, Thank you CB for expressing your opinion & not being daunted by the travelgolf bloggers who couch rude, racist & sometimes sexist feeling in being "ANTI-PC".
"he has always done his best to present himself in a colorblind manner. "
As much as i admire the person who doesnt drag race into everything, its impossible to be colorblind in America. We're just not meant to be that way, we're all different & we have a VERY strong American history to prove it. Tiger is his own man, makes his own decisions, and as the only Black golfer (or Coblinasian), everything seems to fall on HIS head, which isnt fair. But being colorblind isnt the answer, education is.
Permalink
01/24/08 @ 20:06 Leave a comment:
CB Maxwell
a WorldGolf.com Blog
CB Maxwell's golf blog covers everything from the PGA and LPGA tours to the golf equipment and course reviews. A lover of the game, Maxwell brings his passion for golf to WorldGolf.com.
Feeds and archives
Add to:
 
|
Archives
|
